Diamonds Ice Cream Reviews, Ratings & Menu

General Info

Nestled in the heart of Columbus at 5461 Bethel Sawmill Center, Diamonds Ice Cream is the ultimate spot for anyone craving a sweet escape. From the moment you step inside, the lively atmosphere and colorful displays make it impossible not to feel excited about what’s on the menu. Whether you’re popping in for a quick treat or picking up dessert to enjoy at home, this ice cream shop has something for everyone.

One of the highlights that keeps locals coming back is the Mangonada. Bursting with fresh mango flavor, a hint of chili, and topped with chewy tamarind candy, it’s a bold and unforgettable treat. If you’re looking for something creamy and classic, the Ice Cream Go To offers rich flavors that melt perfectly in your mouth. And don’t miss the Absolutely, a unique creation that mixes playful textures with a refreshing sweetness that pairs well with a sunny afternoon.

For those who love chilled drinks, the Horchata here is a must-try. Smooth, cinnamon-infused, and slightly sweet, it complements the vibrant selection of frozen treats. The Water Popsicle is another fan favorite-perfect for cooling down on a warm day with its refreshing, fruity taste. Every item on the menu feels thoughtfully prepared, showing the care Diamonds Ice Cream puts into their offerings.

The shop is designed to make your visit as convenient as possible. In-store shopping is easy and inviting, and if you’re in a rush, takeout options ensure you can enjoy your favorites anywhere. The location features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it easy for everyone to get in and grab a treat. While there’s no table service, the process is quick and simple, with NFC mobile payments available for a smooth checkout experience.

Regular visitors often praise Diamonds Ice Cream in their reviews for both the friendly staff and the vibrant, high-quality treats. Whether you’re exploring new flavors or sticking to your favorites, every visit feels personal and fun. This Columbus gem perfectly blends classic ice cream shop charm with modern convenience, making it a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike.

The combination of signature dishes, easy-to-navigate services, and inviting location makes Diamonds Ice Cream a standout among other dessert spots in Columbus. Each menu item, from the Mangonada to the Horchata, showcases creativity while staying approachable, ensuring a delightful experience for anyone stopping by.

What customers say?

“ Stopped in at Diamonds for some sweet refreshment, and the Force was definitely with these popsicles. I ordered an Orange & Cream and a Kiwi Strawberry—both were out-of-this-galaxy good. The orange was creamy, smooth, and nostalgic, while the kiwi strawberry had bright, fresh flavors with real fruit slices that made it feel extra special. The staff were friendly, helpful, and patient while I browsed the many flavors of paletas and ice creams. With so many choices (everything from classics to adventurous picks like avocado and rice pudding), there’s definitely something here for every Padawan and Jedi Master alike. If you’re searching for homemade popsicles, ice cream, and unique flavors at great quality, this spot doesn’t disappoint. I’ll be back to explore more flavors soon! ”

- Dain Vossar (Galaxy Wanderer) -

“ Came here to try their paletas. I got the fruity pebbles and kiwi strawberry mango paletas. They have a very large selection of items to choose from that'll make you want to come again to try more of their items. I will be coming back to try their elote and bubblegum paletas. Pricing is fair, with paletas being $3.99 a piece and scoops being $5. Staff was nice and helpful, it wasn't very busy but the dining room was organized and clean. Checkout was also simple. I reccomend coming here if you want a quick, indulgent little snack, or if you want to try something new. EDIT : I've seen some people complain about the smell and I just want to make it clear that the smell is corn! That's because they have many menu items that include corn, which probably means they have an abundance of it and it's so much corn that you can smell it. It's actually quite pleasant and it reminds me of home! ”

- Audie Doodah -

“ I’ve gone here a couple times. Hands down some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. The banana split is the best, especially if you get the pistachio ice cream. Highly recommend this place, portions are great. ”

- Chad Bloniarz -

Welcome to Diamonds Ice Cream

General Info

Diamonds Ice Cream menu

Diamonds Ice Cream Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places

Village Mantovani

Poké Station Trois-Rivières

Restaurante Mar Y Cel

Cyclone Anaya's Tex-Mex Kitchen

La Malle Aux Délices